Key Takeaways
- The Electoral College is a compromise system where electors from each state choose the President.
- Each state receives electors equal to its congressional representation.
- The system reflects federalism by giving states a role in presidential selection.
Few aspects of American government generate more controversy than the Electoral College. Every four years, Americans are reminded that the President is elected through this intermediary system.
How It Works
The Electoral College consists of 538 electors. Each state receives electors equal to its total congressional representation. To win, a candidate must receive at least 270 electoral votes.
Most states award all electoral votes to the candidate who wins the state's popular vote (winner-take-all). Only Maine and Nebraska potentially split their votes.
Why the Founders Created It
The Electoral College was a compromise that preserved federalism, protected smaller states, and avoided making the President dependent on Congress or any other branch.
Arguments For
Preserves Federalism: Candidates must build coalitions across states.
Protects Smaller States: The two-senator bonus gives smaller states more weight.
Contains Disputes: Election controversies are contained within individual states.
Arguments Against
Popular Vote Losers Can Win: Five presidents won while losing the popular vote.
Swing State Focus: Candidates concentrate on battleground states.
Unequal Voter Influence: Votes carry different weight in different states.
The Bottom Line
The Electoral College reflects deliberate choices to balance democracy and federalism. Whether those choices serve modern America well is legitimately debated, and informed citizens should understand both sides.
Separation of Powers
Last article in this section