The playbooks
Where the techniques are taught
Political persuasion has published manuals, and operatives in both parties learn from them. A playbook proves a technique exists and is taught. It does not prove that any particular person used it on purpose; that takes their own words.
The classics
Every modern playbook draws on these.
Edward Bernays, Propaganda · 1928
Public opinion can be shaped deliberately by experts working out of sight.
The founding text of modern public relations. Campaigns of both parties descend from it.
Institute for Propaganda Analysis, seven devices · 1937
Name-calling, glittering generalities, transfer, testimonial, plain folks, card stacking, bandwagon.
A ready-made, party-neutral vocabulary for naming techniques.
Leonard Doob, “Goebbels' Principles of Propaganda” · 1950
Reconstructed from Goebbels’ diaries: repetition, simple slogans, timing, labeling enemies.
Lets us name where a technique comes from without calling anyone a Nazi.
RAND, “The Firehose of Falsehood” · 2016
High volume, many channels, fast repetition, no commitment to truth or consistency.
The research behind our glossary terms firehose of falsehood and blitzkrieg.
Used or cited on the left
Documented as taught to progressive organizers and campaigns, except where noted.
Saul Alinsky, Rules for Radicals · 1971
Pressure rules for organizers: ridicule as a weapon; pick a target, freeze it, personalize it, polarize it.
Taught in organizing for decades. Tea Party trainers handed it out too.
George Lakoff, Don't Think of an Elephant! · 2004
Framing: the words you choose set the mental frame, and facts that don’t fit bounce off.
Written explicitly as a guide for progressives.
Drew Westen, The Political Brain · 2007
Voters decide by emotion first; lead with feeling and story, not policy lists.
Widely read by Democratic strategists.
Race-Class Narrative (Demos and partners) · 2018
Name “divide and conquer” racial appeals and pair that with a cross-racial economic message.
Tested and taught to progressive campaigns and unions.
Indivisible Guide · 2016
Town halls, office visits and phone calls aimed at members of Congress.
Openly modeled on the Tea Party’s tactics.
Cloward and Piven, “The Weight of the Poor” · 1966
Proposed enrolling everyone eligible for welfare to overload the system and force a guaranteed income.
Cited mainly by critics. No evidence it is a working playbook today.
Used or cited on the right
Direct counterparts to most of the above.
Frank Luntz, Words That Work · 2007
Focus-group-tested wording; what matters is what people hear. Credited with “death tax.”
Used by Republican campaigns since the 1990s.
GOPAC, “Language: A Key Mechanism of Control” · 1990
Two word lists: hopeful words for your side, and contrasting words to attach to opponents (decay, corruption, radical).
The clearest written example of a label list.
Morton Blackwell, “Laws of the Public Policy Process” · 1979–
Being right is not enough to win; organization, training and numbers decide.
Core of Leadership Institute training.
Tea Party organizing · 2009
Town-hall pressure on members of Congress.
The model Indivisible later copied.
Steve Bannon, “flood the zone” · 2018
Overwhelm the press with so much material it cannot keep up.
A stated strategy, not a book. Closest match to the firehose model.
Same technique, both sides
Where one side has no written playbook, we say so rather than forcing a match.
| Technique | Left source | Right source |
|---|---|---|
| Framing and word choice | Lakoff | Luntz |
| Label lists and name-calling | Alinsky: personalize, polarize | GOPAC contrasting words |
| Emotion over evidence | Westen | Luntz |
| Pressure on officials | Indivisible | Tea Party |
| Volume to overwhelm | No published playbook found | Bannon, “flood the zone” |
| Organization over argument | Alinsky | Blackwell |